Clue or Cluedo is one of the best detective games ever. You need to identify the murderer, the weapon, and the location of the crime – but the answers differ from game to game. But, wait a second! Are Clue and Cluedo the same? Let’s see the differences between Clue vs Cluedo to make sure that you buy the right game!
After reading this article, you will understand better about:
- The suitable audience that can play each game comfortably
- How many players that can play together in the game
- The reason why Clue and Cluedo have different names
- The differences between Clue vs Clue in the gameplay elements
- Which title that is generally more recommended for you
Before everything else, it should be kept in mind that Clue and Cluedo are essentially the same game. There are minor differences between the two, but these differences won’t affect the gameplay experience. Clue or Cluedo is a murder mystery game. The premise is that there is a murder victim, and the players assume the roles of the suspects who are all attempting to find the true murderer. See also: Pandemic vs Pandemic Legacy.
As mentioned before, the game requires you to identify three things correctly, which are the murderer, the weapon, and the location of the crime. You can do this by moving around the game board strategically, in order to collect clues and eventually deduce the correct answers.
Cluedo is designed for 2 – 6 players. Although there are six suspects in the game, you don’t need to use all of the character tokens, meaning that the game can be played with fewer than six players. According to the box, Clue vs Cluedo is suitable for ages 8 years old and over. Cluedo mainly requires deduction skill. There are so many possibilities for the answers, but you can eliminate some of them as you collect more and more clues.
One game typically takes about 60 minutes to complete. However, if a player is really good in deduction or is just lucky with their guess, the game technically can end within less than 30 minutes.
Since the first release in 1949, Cluedo has become very popular. The game has been relaunched a few times, and is now published by Hasbro. Even after so many decades, Cluedo is still selling well. Not only that; the game has also inspired several books, a film, a musical adaptation, and several games. While the original game is still available, which is marketed as “the classic detective game”, several spinoffs with altered or added mechanics have been released as well.
Why are they named differently?
The game was designed by Anthony E. Pratt, an English musician and pianist. He came up with the idea of the game during the Second World War, when he was working in a factory that produced components for tanks. However, it was not until 1944 that he applied for the patent of the game.
Shortly after that, he and his wife presented the game to Waddingtons, which was a game publisher in the United Kingdom. The company immediately purchased the game and gave the trademark name “Cluedo”. This name came up from a play on the word “clue” and “ludo”. The word ludo was used in the country to refer to simple games with dice rolls and moving tokens.
The patent of the game was granted in 1947. However, due to the post-war conditions, Waddingtons delayed the launch until 1949. At around the same time as the first launch in the United Kingdom, the game was licensed to Parker Brothers for publication in the United States. Parker Brothers renamed the game into simply “Clue” and also changed a few minor aspects to make the game more suitable for the US market.
Slightly Different Characters
So, Clue is the US version, whereas Cluedo is the UK version. The game was invented in the United Kingdom, for sure. Although Clue vs Cluedo are essentially the same game, there are some minor differences that are resulted from the adaptation by Parker Brothers. It is mostly about the naming of the characters.
Firstly, the murder victim in Clue is named Mr. Boddy. Meanwhile, the murder victim in Cluedo is Dr. Black.
Secondly, Clue has a character named Miss Scarlet. In Cluedo, this character is named Miss Scarlett.
Thirdly, Clue has a character named Mr. Green. The same character is named Rev. Green in Cluedo.
Fourth, some of the weapons in Clue are knife, Colt M1911 pistol, and monkey wrench. Instead of those weapons, Cluedo has dagger, Dreyse M1907 pistol, and spanner.
As you can see, the differences are rather trivial. The different names and objects are used in order to make Clue and Cluedo feel more familiar and easier to grasp for their markets. Obviously, these differences won’t affect the actual gameplay of the game. So, you don’t really need to worry about which one to choose between Clue vs Cluedo if you just want to play the classic version of the detective game.
However, some Clue and Cluedo boxes are a little bit more expensive than the others because they include a battery-powered magic mirror. This fancy device is completely optional. It is used to hold the answer cards without showing the content. When you press the button, the device will light up and causing its mirror to turn transparent, hence showing the answer cards. You can play without this device simply by putting the answer cards face-down.
Cluedo uses a game board that features several corridors, rooms, and secret passages. The setting is an English country house located in Hampshire, England, 1926. There are six character tokens representing the suspects. There are also three sets of cards representing the characters, weapons, and rooms.
The box also includes two dice, an envelope (or the magic mirror) to hold the answer cards, and a detective note pad which has lists of characters, weapons, and rooms so that the players can keep detailed notes throughout the game. At the beginning of the game, the character tokens are placed at their respective start spaces as indicated on the board.
One suspect card, one weapon card, and one room card are chosen randomly and put into the envelope. These cards are the answers for the current case. The remaining cards are then shuffled and dealt to the players.
In the original version, the play is started from Miss Scarlett, and then the turn goes clockwise. However, some modern versions decide the first turn by requiring the players to roll dice, and the player with the highest roll starts first.
In your turn, you roll the dice and then move your character token along the corridor spaces or into rooms according to the roll result. After entering a room, you may make a suggestion which includes the name of the suspect, weapon, and room.
You must include the room that you are currently in when making a suggestion, and you can’t make a suggestion in a corridor. For example, when in a dining room, you may say “I suggest it was Rev. Green, with the candlestick, in the dining room.” You are allowed to name your own character as the murderer. Next, the tokens of the suspect and weapon mentioned in your suggestion should be put in your current room.
After a player proposes a suggestion, the other players are called to disprove. If they have one or more cards of the three cards mentioned in the suggestion (suspect, weapon, murder), they must show these cards privately to the player who suggested. Once all the other players have disproved if they can, or if no one can disprove, the turn ends. The next player may take his or her turn.
If your character is moved into a different room due to another player’s suggestion, you may make a suggestion immediately when your turn comes up. Otherwise, you may move out from the room by rolling the dice as usual.
By the way, a player is not allowed to make multiple suggestions in a row in the same room. If you want to make another suggestion in the room, you need to spend at least one turn outside the room and try to go back into the room.
You need to make as many suggestions as possible to gain information. Since there are limited copies of the cards, you will eventually deduce which cards that are contained in the envelope. Once you are certain of the answers, you may make an accusation.
The accusation may be delivered right after a suggestion that is not disproved, but the accusation may use any room. Then, you may check the cards in the envelope secretly. If you are correct, you show the cards to the others and you win. If you are wrong, you lose and you may not participate any longer in the game.
Clue vs Cluedo
|Key features||- Named by Parker Brothers for the US market - The victim character is Mr. Boddy - There are characters Miss Scarlet and Mr. Green - Some weapons are knife, Colt M1911 pistol, and monkey wrench||- Named by Waddingtons for the UK market - The victim character is Dr. Black - There are characters Miss Scarlett and Rev. Green - Some weapons are dagger, Dreyse M1907 pistol, and spanner|
|Best Offer||Save Money Please click here||Save Money Please click here|
Clue is the US version of the game, whereas Cluedo is the UK version. They are essentially the same game with just minor differences that won’t affect the actual gameplay. The differences are the naming of the characters and some of the weapon objects. Both Clue and Cluedo are really great detective games that can be enjoyed by players of any age who like strategy and deducing games.