If you are looking for a fun party game in which you and your friends can have some good laughs, you may be interested in Rotten Apples vs Cards Against Humanity. These are card-based games filled with adult jokes and pop culture topics. So, which one is the best for your group? See the comparison below to find out.
Continue reading below to find out more about:
– The recommended number of players and average game length
– The rules of Rotten Apples and Cards Against Humanity
– Which game that is generally funnier and more interesting
– The repeatability of Rotten Apples vs Cards Against Humanity
– The available expansion packs on each game
– Which party game that is generally better
Suitable Players & Game Length
Before we delve further, let’s take a look at the recommendations provided by these games’ makers. It can give you some idea about who can play these games comfortably and how long that each game is going to take. Party games won’t be fun if they are not suitable for the group. See also: Cards Against Humanity vs Personally Incorrect.
Rotten Apples clearly says that it is an adult party game. On the packaging, the age recommendation is 17 years old or over. This game is meant to be played by mature teenagers and adults. You should avoid playing this game when there are children around, as the content is filled with adult jokes and dual suggestive meanings.
The box also mentions that each game requires 2 – 10 players. Rotten Apples vs Cards Against Humanity can be a fun way to spend time with your friends, but it is not really recommended when the crowd has more than ten people. Each game with standard rules is estimated to last for about 30 minutes.
Cards Against Humanity
Cards Against Humanity is also an adult party game designed for people of at least 17 years old or over. So, it is meant to be played by mature teenagers and adults. It is not suitable for children. Some families may be intrigued to play this game due to the popularity, but keep in mind that you need to avoid playing this game when there are children nearby.
This game can be quite larger. Cards Against Humanity is recommended for 4 – 20 players. So, it is suitable for a small group of close friends as well as a big crowd of classmates. The estimated time for one game with standard rules is 30 – 90 minutes. The length of the game may vary depending on the number of players. When there are more players, you will need to spend more time reading the responses, thereby increasing the game length.
How to Play
The base concepts of Rotten Apples vs Cards Against Humanity are quite similar. In every round, you are required to provide a response card to a prompt. The player with the funniest card combination wins the round and gets a point. The winner of the game is the one with the highest score. However, the details in these games may be slightly different.
In Rotten Apples, there are two kinds of cards: brown cards and green cards. Every brown card has a fill-in-the-blank sentence. Every green card has random words which are used to fill the sentence.
At the beginning of each round, every player draws ten green cards. Then, one of the players becomes a judge – the standard rule says that the judge is a player whose birthday is the closest to January 4, but it can be altered as needed. Next, the judge picks a brown card and read the content out loud.
Every other player should choose one green card with an answer that they believe can fit the sentence, and give the card face-down to the judge. The judge shuffles the received green cards and reads them out loud. The answer doesn’t need to be logical; being comical is the point. The judge then chooses the funniest answer, and the player that provided the card wins the round. This player keeps the brown card as well and becomes the new judge for the next round.
The game is continued until a player holds three brown cards. Once a player has three brown cards, he or she is declared as the winner of the game.
Cards Against Humanity
In Cards Against Humanity, there are two kinds of cards as well. They are black cards and white cards. Every black card contains a question or a fill-in-the-blank sentence. Every white card contains a random response to answer the question or complete the sentence.
Each round is started with every player drawing ten white cards. Next, a player is chosen to be the Card Czar. They should take one black card and read it out loud. Every other player provides a white card to the Card Czar as a response to the black card. Note that a black card may sometimes require two white cards. Afterwards, the Card Czar shuffles the provided white cards and reads them one by one.
The winner of the round is chosen by the Card Czar that they find the funniest. The winner of the round gets one Awesome Point and become the next Card Czar.
When the party is ready to stop playing, the official way to end the game is by playing the “Make a Haiku” black card. Every player picks three white cards to make a haiku. You don’t need to rhyme them; just read them in a dramatic way for a comical effect. Finally, the player with the most Awesome Points is declared as the winner of the game.
Although Rotten Apples vs Cards Against Humanity are similar in terms of base concept and age recommendation, they are still two different games with different feels. Depending on who is around, either Rotten Apples or Cards Against Humanity will be more suitable for your game night.
Rotten Apples is generally fun and enjoyable. If you are familiar with similar games like Apples to Apples and Cards Against Humanity, you will find that Rotten Apples is relatively mild in mature themes. It is nothing innocent like Apples to Apples, but it doesn’t get too vulgar or offensive like Cards Against Humanity.
As the effect, Rotten Apples can be a great choice if you want to play a funny adult game but some of your friends have more delicate humor values. It is pretty safe and less likely to offend anyone. That said, it is still funny, and the dual suggestive meanings of the cards will ensure that everybody can have some good laughs.
Due to the relatively safe nature, the card combinations won’t be too shocking. But some of them are indeed really good. For new players who are not yet familiar with the cards, most responses can be quite surprising. So, the first impression of this game is good.
The pace of the game is also good. It is not too fast, and not too slow. The game is easy and simple to understand. New players will quickly grasp the basic rules in the first round. It is an easy game to pick up.
Cards Against Humanity
Cards Against Humanity is hilarious. Note that the content can be really vulgar. Sometimes, the topics can be a bit offensive, but as long as nobody takes things seriously in the game, you are all guaranteed to have great laughs. Still, you should pay attention to who is around before pulling out this game.
The first impression of Cards Against Humanity is good. Most of the card combinations are shocking and surprising. Most people find it funnier and more intriguing than Rotten Apples, but keep in mind that it is not suitable for everybody. It is great for a group of people with a relatively similar humor sense.
The game is really easy to pick up. New players can immediately join the game, and they have the same chance of winning as every other player. The game has a good pacing.
Since the winner of every round is chosen by the Card Czar, the round won’t get too long. However, when there are a lot of players in the group, reading the response one by one can be a bit time-consuming. When the game is extended too long, the game may become a bit dull, even though the card combinations are still funny. So, it is a wise idea to limit the game to a certain number of rounds.
How about the repeatability of Rotten Apples vs Cards Against Humanity? Although a game can be really fun at first, it won’t become a staple for our game nights if it gets dull and stale too quickly. Finding a party game with good repeatability is important if you and your friends often gather together.
One standard pack of Rotten Apples has 520 cards. It consists of 65 brown cards and 455 answer cards. There is also an instruction booklet included.
Rotten Apples has pretty good repeatability. There are plenty of cards available in the standard pack, so it will take some time for you to get to know them all. This game is also good if you often play with different groups of people.
However, once you get familiar with most of the cards (don’t worry, this will take a pretty long time), it may start to feel stale and boring. Some people may prefer to keep certain green cards for certain prompts. And there is nothing more boring than hearing the same jokes over and over again. So, it also depends on the people to be creative with their answers.
Unfortunately, there is expansion pack currently available for Rotten Apples. So, you will need to stick with the same cards, at least until an expansion pack is available. Or, you can craft your own cards to add into the stack.
Cards Against Humanity
One standard pack of Cards Against Humanity has a total of 600 cards. There are 100 black cards and 500 white cards. A copy of the game guide is included in the box.
Cards Against Humanity has very good repeatability. It has more cards than Rotten Apples, so you can play with just the standard pack for quite a long time. You won’t get too familiar with the cards too quickly, and the game won’t become boring anytime soon. This game is also great if played with different groups of people.
The game guide is great. Besides explaining the basic rules in a simple and easy-to-grasp manner, there are also several alternative rules provided. You can use one of these alternative rules to twist and spice up the game. So, the game can be fresh and interesting even if you have played it multiple times.
Still, Cards Against Humanity can get stale eventually. After you get to know most of the cards, the jokes may become a bit boring. This is a good time to expand the card stack. You can choose one of the many expansion packs available, or create your own cards. It will keep the game fun and intriguing for a bit longer.
Finally, let’s take a look at the available expansions packs on Rotten Apples and Cards Against Humanity. Choosing a good expansion pack can make the game even more interesting, especially if your group likes a specific topic or niche.
Rotten Apples doesn’t have any expansion pack yet. This may change in the future, but there aren’t many ways to expand the game for now. It is possible to make your own cards, but making similar-looking cards may require some time and effort. Besides, the official website doesn’t provide any template for custom cards.
Cards Against Humanity
Cards Against Humanity has many expansions packs. So, you are not limited to just the standard set. There are three kinds of expansion packs available, which are:
– The Color Packs (Red, Blue, Green). They are the older expansions. They contain more general jokes. Each pack contains 300 new cards. They are great for expanding the standard set.
– The Specialty Packs. There are many options here, including the Sci-Fi Pack, Period Pack, Pride Pack, Theatre Pack, 90s Nostalgia Pack, and Weed Pack. Each pack contains 30 new cards. They are great for groups that understand specific niches.
– The Holiday Packs. They are the cheapest options, but each pack only has 30 cards. They contain mostly general jokes and holiday-related jokes.
You can also make your own cards. Just head to the official website and download the template. This is really great if you want to customize the game for your friends.
Rotten Apples vs Cards Against Humanity
|Brand||Rotten Apples||Cards Against Humanity|
|Key features||- Includes 520 cards (455 Answer Cards and 65 Prompt cards) and instruction booklet! - Players each choose green cards they think best fit the prompt. Cards with dual suggestive meanings will surprise all! - Apples Picker selects their favorite "answer." If you card is picked you win the round and become the next Apple Picker!||- Cards Against Humanity is a party game for horrible people. - Now version 2.0! Over 150 new cards since the last version. - Contains 500 white cards and 100 black cards for maximum replayability.|
|Best Offer||Save Money Please click here||Save Money Please click here|
In general, Cards Against Humanity is more recommended. It is funnier and more hilarious. It also has better repeatability. There are a lot of expansion packs available – you can even make your own cards. However, the mature and vulgar themes of the game require you to pay attention to who is around before pulling out the game.